PR #74 Test Report: Add fieldRef Feature to shellEnvVars

Summary

This report documents testing of PR #74, which adds fieldRef functionality to shellEnvVars in the function-shell project. The feature allows dynamic environment variable population from Crossplane resource fields with optional policies and default values.

Test Environment

• Function Version: xpkg.upbound.io/upbound/function-shell:v0.7.0
• Test Branch: pr-74
• Kubernetes Cluster: Local development cluster
• Testing Approach: Both local development mode and in-cluster deployment

Test Results Summary

✅ All tests passed successfully

• Local unit tests: 11/11 passed
• Local integration tests: 4/4 scenarios validated
• In-cluster deployment: Successfully deployed and functional
• End-to-end testing: fieldRef features working correctly

Detailed Test Results

1. Unit Test Results

=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromContextMissingFieldOptionalPolicyDefaultValue
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromCompositeValid
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromCompositeMissingError
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromCompositeMissingFieldOptionalPolicyDefaultValue
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromCompositeMissingFieldOptionalPolicyNoDefaultValue
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromContextMissingError
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromContextMissingErrorDefaultPolicy
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromCompositeMissingErrorDefaultPolicy
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromContextValid
=== RUN   TestFromFieldRef/FromContextMissingFieldOptionalPolicyNoDefaultValue
--- PASS: TestFromFieldRef (0.00s)

=== RUN   TestRunFunction
--- PASS: TestRunFunction (0.03s)
    --- PASS: TestRunFunction/ResponseIsEchoEnvVarFieldRefDefaultValue (0.00s)

PASS
ok  	github.com/crossplane-contrib/function-shell	0.367s

Result: All 11 unit tests pass, including coverage of fieldRef scenarios.

2. Local Integration Testing

Test Case 1: Optional Field with Default Value

Input XR:

spec:
  field: "hello from the XR"
  # optional field intentionally omitted

Expected Result: Use composition default value
Actual Result: ✅

echo: hello from the XR optional: defaultValue from Composition

Test Case 2: Optional Field with Actual Value

Input XR:

spec:
  field: "hello from the XR"
  optional: "optional from the XR"

Expected Result: Use actual field value
Actual Result: ✅

echo: hello from the XR optional: optional from the XR

Test Case 3: Status Field Reference

Input XR with pre-populated status:

status:
  atFunction:
    shell:
      stdout: "previous output from shell"

Expected Result: Conditional logic based on status field
Actual Result: ✅

echo: hello from the XR optional: optional from the XR
status.atFunction.shell.stdout is populated

Test Case 4: Required Field Error Handling

Input: Missing required field spec.nonexistent

Expected Result: Error with descriptive message
Actual Result: ✅

Error: cannot get observed composite value at spec.nonexistent: spec.nonexistent: no such field

3. In-Cluster Deployment Testing

Deployment

• Result: ✅ Function successfully deployed and healthy

End-to-End Validation

Final In-Cluster Test Result:

status:
  atFunction:
    shell:
      stderr: ""
      stdout: |-
        echo: hello from the XR optional: defaultValue from Composition
        status.atFunction.shell.stdout is populated
  conditions:
  - reason: ReconcileSuccess
    status: "True"
    type: Synced
  - reason: Available
    status: "True"
    type: Ready

Validation Points:

• ✅ fieldRef resolving spec.field correctly
• ✅ Optional policy using default value for missing spec.optional
• ✅ Status field reference for conditional logic
• ✅ Function executing successfully with ReconcileSuccess
• ✅ XR marked as Ready and Available

Feature Capabilities Verified

Core fieldRef Functionality

• ✅ Field Path Resolution: fieldRef.path correctly resolves nested field paths
• ✅ Optional Policy: fieldRef.policy: Optional gracefully handles missing fields
• ✅ Required Policy: fieldRef.policy: Required provides strict validation with clear error messages
• ✅ Default Values: fieldRef.defaultValue provides fallback values when fields are missing
• ✅ Context Support: Function supports both composite resource and context field references
• ✅ Type Safety: Proper JSON marshalling/unmarshalling with correct Go struct tags

Integration Points

• ✅ Composition Integration: fieldRef works in Crossplane compositions
• ✅ Pipeline Mode: Function operates correctly in Crossplane pipeline mode
• ✅ Crossplane Runtime: Compatible with Crossplane function SDK and runtime

Error Handling & Edge Cases

• ✅ Missing Required Fields: Clear error messages with field path information
• ✅ Empty Field Paths: Validation prevents empty path configurations
• ✅ Invalid Field Paths: Proper error handling for non-existent paths
• ✅ Policy Validation: Enum validation for Optional/Required policies
• ✅ Default Value Handling: Empty string defaults work correctly

Code Quality Assessment

Implementation Quality

• Go Code: Well-structured with proper error handling and type safety
• CRD Schema: OpenAPI v3 schema with validation rules
• Test Coverage: Unit test coverage
• Documentation: Clear field descriptions and usage examples

API Design

• Consistency: fieldRef design follows Kubernetes patterns (similar to fieldRef in pods)
• Flexibility: Supports both optional and required field resolution
• Extensibility: Design allows for future enhancements without breaking changes

Recommendation

✅ APPROVE FOR MERGE

PR #74 successfully implements the fieldRef feature with:

• Functionality covering specified requirements
• Error handling with clear error messages
• Test coverage including unit, integration, and end-to-end tests
• Production readiness validated in-cluster deployment
• Clean implementation following Kubernetes patterns and best practices

The feature enhances the function-shell capabilities by enabling dynamic environment variable population from Crossplane resource fields, which is essential for building flexible and reusable compositions.

Test Artifacts

Generated Files

• Clean CRD schema: package/input/shell.fn.crossplane.io_parameters.yaml
• Updated Go types: input/v1alpha1/parameters.go
• Test configurations: Multiple test YAML files for various scenarios

Package Information

• Test Package: xpkg.upbound.io/...test-org.../function-shell:v0.7.0
• Build Method: Complete clean rebuild
• Deployment Status: Successfully deployed and operational in Kubernetes cluster

Report Generated: August 18, 2025
Tested By: Claude Code Assistant and Markus
Test Duration: Multi-stage testing over multiple iterations